Wednesday, March 23, 2011

From Back Home (exhibition at the National Media Museum in Bradford, Yorkshire)


FROM BACK HOME

An exhibition of photographs by Anders Petersen and JH Engstrom at the National Media Museum in Bradford, Yorkshire.


I attach this rather shoddy looking photograph of the Cadbury's factory taken from the train as it exemplifies the kind of loosely constructed image that appears in the Back From Home exhibition; the colour castes over the image come from reflections in the train window.

I came to this exhibition misinformed, thinking it was about landscape and hence was surprised perhaps disappointed to find it was more about place and people, nevertheless a fitting subject for someone presently engaged in the OCA People and Place module. The photograph used to advertise the exhibition was of a fleeting horse with a house in the background; this image suggested romanticism yet the subject matter was generally much more down to earth than that. At first, the banality of the photography struck me since much of the imagery was concerned with hedonistic activity that might well be considered life but not necessarily what everyone would consider life. I felt I was being challenged by these images, being made aware of my comfort zone; this made it worthwhile making the long journey up from the south since I came as a student, ready to learn.

This body of work has been described as being concerned with “experience, memory and the human condition.” It is the result of a seven year collaboration between the two photographers about an area in Central West Sweden called Varmland where they had both spent their formative years. The work is described as “an intense voyage of discovery into both the place and the people that shaped them.”

The first series of photographs I looked at were by JH Engstrom in which he uses a camera with flash to photograph people, resulting in dark studio like backgrounds. Some of these images are in colour, those of the more elderly people in black and white; the young are often photographed full body length while the elderly are more likely to be pictured with head and shoulders. Many of these images are of couples embracing.

There are other images that are more general views that include house interiors, chickens by their hutch, and landscapes often from an aerial perspective. Some large frames contain a collection of photographs collaged together. Engstrom writes of this work …

These images pay homage
To the people and landscapes that are my origins.
I return to something my body and emotions recognise.

The other part of this exhibition shows Anders Peterson’s work. His images are also mostly of people with backgrounds that say something but not much about the area under consideration. There is not much sense of composition in these images, they are beyond formalism; the subject matter is much more important. Anders Petersen writes of this work that it contains “little hard memories of sad and lonely times” yet there is more to these words that appear on the exhibition wall for he continues by saying “there is also a streak of warm confidence”. He also writes that “my memories can never be destroyed, because they no longer end in themselves.”


This exhibition suffers perhaps because it was not arranged by the photographers themselves; a more formal rather than de-constructivist hand has been at work. This exhibition comes “from a well-established tradition of stream-of-consciousness, diaristic photography. Born out of existential thinking … less objective photography.”

The free brochure accompanying the exhibition also states that this collection of photographs “elegantly demonstrates the power of photography to be intimate and personal, while accessible to the viewer” while “images are affectionate, sometimes brutal and sometimes funny” evoking “contradictory, yet complementary emotions” that make this exhibition noteworthy.


The next part of the day was a CONVERSATION BETWEEN JH ENGSTROM AND GREG HOBSON: in other words, one of the contributing photographers and the exhibition curator. The other photographer Anders Petersen had been advised not to travel to Bradford on the advice of his doctor; this was a little disappointing since he was the older of the two photographers and the mentor of the younger Engstrom.


JH Engstrom photographer at the National Media Museum

Engstrom sat in pensive pose as he listened to Hobson talking; the session began with Hobson asking Engstrom questions.

How did Engstrom find his way into photography? He does not find this an easy question to answer and yet his reply is interesting. As a young boy of ten, he was taken to Paris where he lived with his family for a couple of years or so. Everyday he had to make his way across town to attend the Swedish School and during this somewhat complicated journey, he witnessed many scenes of life some of which included violence; this had a tremendous impact on him. Later, the camera helped him to formulate such experiences and he has received a formal photographic education. He moved back to Paris and met someone who made him aware that photography is an interesting medium through which a living can be made. He begged the well-known fashion photographer Mario Testino for a job, telling him that he admired his work when in fact he had never seen it! However, he found he was not really attracted to fashion photography and preferred taking film to the lab for processing since it allowed him time to read on the metro. There is a need to be serious about one’s work (connected with it rather than half-hearted). He came into contact with Anders Petersen who eventually accepted him as a student when Engstrom became desperate; they became close, not just teacher and student but also like father and son. He then did a photo-book called Shelter about a place for homeless people; this was made in a the classic documentary tradition and the book proved to be a success, winning a photographic book of the year award in Sweden.

Engstrom is exploring the subject through the subject. Photography is a language and ultimately the photograph, although it contains imagery is just a piece of paper.

Hobson remarked that when people come and show him their portfolios, he often advises them not to mix colour with black and white photography yet he notices that Engstrom has done this during his exhibition. Engstrom answers directly by saying, “You gave them bad advice!”

Engstrom is still largely an analogue, black and white photographer, who also uses large format cameras as well as throwaway cameras in some cases!

Peoples response to the camera has changed hence some of the old approaches do not work.

Engstrom uses darkroom techique such as that of overexposing prints.

Photography is about everything except reality; there is a dreamy, imaginary feel to Engstrom’s work and also a graphic quality.

We see a slide show of Engstrom’s work that is centred around his wife, her pregnancy, their son … only at the end are we shown that this was a Ceasarean birth which suddenly brings together what at first seemed like a disconnected group of images. The images might seem shallow, poorly constructed but they are about life and one cannot argue with that.

There then follows a film about Anders Petersen, the absent photographer, and we enter into his hedonistic world in which he seems to be smoking and drinking himself slowly to death. Petersen talks of his love of connecting with others and that this is the premise for photography. In the film, Engstrom advises him to take care of himself and it ends on a positive note by saying that Petersen has given up his 2 boxes of cigarettes a day habit and is now producing some of his best work.

Engstrom now accepted questions from the audience. Gareth Dent of the Open College of the Arts asked why there were so many young people in his photographs of the Varmland; Engstrom replied that this was probably because he grew up there and was young there.

The concept of place can be very personal as well as empirical, ethnographic, when the emphasis is on the place being documented.


OCA tutor, Alan Whetton, who remarked after I took this photograph, that it was "uncalled for"! Possibly it was but its' a nice photo to attach to my blog and helps 
put a human face to the OCA.
The next and final part of the day was the meeting with other students from the OCA including Gareth Dent, OCA CEO, and Alan Whetton, a photographic tutor with whom I had had a short chat before the session with Engstrom. Alan mentioned that there were a lot of difficult images in the exhibition and the slide show that were not easy to resonate with.

One saw the hard life of the artist being portrayed. Possibly the melancholy of Swedish life, a country that is said to have the highest suicide rate in the world.

I said that I felt that both these photographers were more artists than photographers, a statement that Gareth asked me to justify. At the time I could not and I also felt that it might steer the discussion away from the general topic of the photographers and the exhibition. In hindsight, I can write that both the photographers seemed to be shooting with a disregard for the basics of photography (composition, depth of field etc) and by so-doing were making works of art rather than documents; generally speaking, photography is concerned with both document and art and when one deviates from either by going to an extreme, for instance photographing bacteria through a microscope would be another extreme, one starts to loose the essence of photography although images of bacteria might be both colourful and contain designs. As a student, I do not want to be drawn too far in either direction except on a temporary basis as my work might cease to become relevant and suffer from self indulgence.

Gareth thinks that I have found a certain area of photography and am happy with that. He is right and yet I attend such days with the OCA because I do want to see the wider implications of photography which I see as sharing ground with art but in danger of being swallowed up by art and hence loosing its’ uniquesness as an expressive medium. This is not as eccentric a view as might be presumed as Roland Barthes, many of course question his view of photography, mentions at the end of his book that photography is wild and art threatens to tame it.

Alan Whetton praises the work of Engstrom and Petersen as being honest and intimate.

Gareth notes that Engstrom looked very uncomfortable during the discussion and asks me for a photograph to show that!

His photography is mostly about himself, his search.


As Alan Whetton talks, the OCA group listens

Alan comments that when he goes out to photograph, he has a plan, an objective. With Fay Godwin, everything was calculated since apart from taking great care with her compositions, often waiting around till the light was right, while she also used Ordanance Survey maps!

The approach of Petersen and Engstrom is much more spontaneous and yet there is a plan with Petersen who deliberately draws his subjects out exuding a public persona with bravado to match in order to make his images.

What did I gain from seeing this exhibition? Probably a much better understanding of an approach to photography that often strikes me as banal yet worthwhile since it does show something of life and may prove to be an interesting document of our time.

There is however, as others comment, nothing here to uplift one. One senses darkness and negativity not only in the images but also in the photographers.

Could work like this be made in the UK!?

The photographers know their subject very well and have produced it well. I can not help but wonder how accurate a document it is though of the Varmland and what the reactions of people who live there might be to such an exhibition. Is it really about the Varmland or something else!?

Alan mentions that he is re-photographing some of the places that Fay Godwin photographed while in Bradford and it is interesting to see how much some places have changed and how little other places have.


At the end of the visit, I revisit the exhibition with Gareth and another student. Gareth wonders whether these photographs differ much from the kind of images millions of people put on their Facebook pages. I reckon they differ quite a lot because when one examines them one sees they are well constructed for the most part in spite of their initial amateurish appearance; they are of course also framed prints and not merely images.

A lot of the people portrayed in Petersen’s seminal book CafĂ© Lehmitz are pictured as being close but are not intimate; there is a kind of friction here.



Monday, March 21, 2011

REFLECTIONS ON THE WORK OF RAGHU RAI


I first met Raghu Rai over 15 years ago when I went to his office at a newspaper he was working for at the time. He looked through some of my photos I had brought him, made some comments and we talked. He wanted to know what number an ordinary skylight filter was as he was planning on changing to one of these, after using a warm-up filter for his work. I knew the answer was a 1A and told him, reflecting upon the fact that I knew more than an accomplished photographer although it mattered little; it was a stark reminder that photography was not about facts or knowledge but seeing. At that moment, I could not see very well and wondered what made Raghu Rai such a renowned photographer other than the fact that he was an established one.

With the launch of an exhibition of Ragu Rai’s in England, I find myself with a gifted copy of the exhibition catalogue that I am going to give to the Open College of the Arts. Before I do so, it seems sensible to reflect upon it. The cover is of a sadhu (holy man) looking straight into the camera with a hypnotic stare. It is not one of Raghu’s most sensitive photographs but it is attention grabbing and hence makes a good book cover; the subject of the photograph also contains a collection of people yet most are not connected with the photographer.

The catalogue contains an introduction by Niru Ratnam entitled Public Space in Raghu Rai’s Photography. A closer examination of this seems pertinent to my OCA course as well as helping me to understand what Raghu Rai’s work is about. The following text is from Niru Ratnam …

“..outdoor space in India, revealing something particular and complex about the relationship between the public sphere and the private sphere in India.”

“…public sphere of India significantly different  … dissolves the easy distinction between public and private.”

“… striking ways in which Rai portrays public space – and to tease out how this is significantly different to Western modernist photographers and other Magnum photographers.”


“ … Rai captures the ordered chaos of public space in India. A profusion of activities takes place but on closer inspection this plenitude is almost choreographed by an unseen hand.” (These comments are made about an older photograph from 1964 called Traffic at Chawri Bazaar, Delhi).


“If we fast-forward forty years to Rai’s recent work, “A Bazaar, Old Delhi” (2006) it becomes clear that the street is still a shared space.”

“In this “three-speed” image (there are three different layers to this photograph visible in a sleeping man, traffic passing and shops in the background), Rai seems to convey the heterogeneity of activity going on.”


“… we can’t simply use terms such as “public space” and “private space” from a Eurocentric perspective.”

“The public spaces that Rai investigates seems to be more layered and more multi-valent …”

“… the large-scale communal religious ritual is a common feature that takes place that takes place within the Indian landscape and that Rai has returned to photographing over the years.”

“… a distinction between the individual and the crowd; a suggestion that in these public  displays of group identity, the individual can break away for time apart if they should so wish.”


“The men sit and wait but somehow by doing this they seem communally joined. They do not seem like the atomized individual that is such a popular trope in Western Modernism.”

“Whilst in the West the religious ritual is almost wholly imagined inside public buildings such as the church or the cathedral, Rai’s work shows that Indian religious ritual is rooted in the landscape.”


“… the idea of public space acting as a stage is present in all of these works .. “

“The idea of stage is heightened by the way Rai captures individuals going about activities that co-opt outdoor public space for some sort of individual or communal function.”


“In a series of recent works made in 2010 Rai has taken this idea of the stage one step further by asking subjects to stand in front of painted backdrops.”

“What is Rai suggesting here? I think that this series suggests that it is impossible to demarcate the boundary between the “real” and the “staged” in documentary photography; the click of a camera produces the stage whether the subjects of the photograph know it or not.”


“… makes us question what exactly is public and what exactly is private; and what is the nature of these everyday acts that we stage in public spaces fr the benefit of ourselves and for the benefit of others.”


Having faithfully recorded some of Niru Ratnam’s comments in an attempt to better understand Raghu Rai’s work, I feel I can also note the way I understand Rai’s work after having looked at it over the years. Firstly, I see it as very informative of a country, India, which is often liked by the outside world but not very well understood. Its’ not just that Raghu Rai’s photographs are extremely well constructed and composed in a way that may delight the eye, their subject matter is also fascinating and meanings at first not apparent might be discovered later. For me then, the appeal of his work is more than just the excellent photography for his images are as much documents as works of art.

Monday, February 21, 2011

more about the Taylor Wessing Portrait Photography prize

I come across this piece of news ... it makes me reflect further on the day I attended at the NPG recently!!


London's National Portrait Gallery has found itself in an embarrassing situation involving one of the judges for its prestigious annual Taylor Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize who, it was recently discovered, is in an intimate relationship with one of the prize winners. The fact only came to light after the couple appeared at the awards ceremony with their young baby.

Harry Borden, an award-winning portrait photographer himself, was chosen back in August 2010 as one of the six judges to determine the four recipients of the coveted prize. By the time the award ceremony was held in November, it was clear that fourth-prize winner Abbie Trayler-Smith was the mother of Borden's child. "It was only at that moment, on that night, that I realized that we should investigate," Sandy Nairne, director of the NGP, told ArtsDesk.com.

The National Portrait Gallery's annual Photographic Portrait Prize draws thousands of applicants each year, serving as a standard by which to judge the leaders in contemporary portrait photography. There are four winners each year and this year's top prize and the accompanying £12,000 went to David Chancellor for his captivating image of a modern-day Diana-esque teenage deer-hunter.

After the revelation of the apparent conflict of interest, an investigation of Borden's actions was conducted by an independent committee and it was determined that Trayler-Smith's prize would not be confiscated, although the kerfuffle has lead the NPG to lay out guidelines for subsequent years, dictating that judges be briefed about declaring conflicts of interest immediately.

Nairne said that Borden told him he did not know that Trayler-Smith had entered the competition when he was asked to judge. Also, since the competition is judged anonymously and the work is reviewed without the names attached, Borden insists that he did not violate any rules.

One might argue, however, that it it would be extremely strange if the subject of the competition never came up over the dinner table, and that it is also unlikely that Borden would not recognize her photograph of an obese teenager from her series entitled "Childhood Obesity." "Obviously it's none of my business to comment on their relationship," stated Nairne diplomatically — although, clearly, Borden himself should have commented so as to avoid the embarassment.

Monday, January 31, 2011

National Portrait Galllery photographic workshop saturday jan 29'th 2011



Like the last workshop I did here, this was a little dissappointing. Perhaps the NPG sees photography as primarily art rather than being infuenced by art? My intention here is not to discuss that but outline what happened during the workshop which overall seemed worthwhile doing. This blog attempts to be a faithfull account of what happened but the views expressed are bound to be coloured by my own view and hence may not accurately reflect what was said at the time.

It was run by Anthony Luvera, a proffessional photographer from Australia, who also teaches at universities in the UK and writes about photography. He considers his approach to portrait photography as being documentary based.

The environment in which a person is photographed is important. The exhibition can be considered as different takes on environmental portraits!

All 12 participants introduced themselves ...

a Japanese man who wanted to brush up his technique
Brazilian woman who wants to get back into photography also interested in technique.
Recently retired British male who wants to make better photographs.

AL(Antony Luvera) interjects here to say that even proffessionals end up with lots of rubbish photographs!

Neuroscientist who likes to photograph
British male who works in radio; likes to make photographs.
Female artist who loves the NPG; photography her hobby.
Female who wants to push herself in photography.
Bank worker who wants to take better photgraphs of his children.
Asian male, a beginner, interested in technique and composition.
Amano, myself, an OCA student who wants to understand what the exhibition is really about.
Mentioned I was taking notes as part of my OCA learning blog. AL responded by encouraging me to do this and sugesting others did likewise ... which they did!

AL talks of understanding contemporary portrait photography. If you want to take better photos, take lots of photographs .. then deconstruct them along lines he'll mention later.

Retired art teacher, female: given camera and this course as a present. Likes garden photography.
AL mentions the book Derek Jameson's Garden

Muslim woman dressed in black robe who works in London; is assisting this workshop. Loves wildlife photography.
Retoucher going freelance; interested in portraiture.

How much does a photographic portrait represent the person portrayed?
How much is the photograph a result of what the photographer wants to say?

AL quotes Lucy Davies from the introduction to the exhibition portfolio ...

A portrait photograph depends on the person pointing the camera.

Is a photograph more engaging when the meaning is not obvious. This approach encourages the viewer to become involved with the image!

An image can be said to be worthwhile if it helps you to see the world differently.

AL uses large format cameras and has the film properly printed rather than scanned; scans from the print if required.

For the exhibition, 60 photographic prints were selected from over 6,000

At least a couple of the judges were documentary based photographers.

When looking at photographs in exhibition, need to consider ...
camera position
composition
environment
the story within the image (what is being played out)
caption - way in which this effects our view!
biodata of photographer

We were asked to look closely at 4 images and consider those ... I found I only had time to look and write about 3! There seemed to be so much to consider when one looked closely and considered the images along the guidlines suggested.

CHARLIE WATTS (Rolling Stones drummer)

The obvious appeal of this image is that it portrays a celebrity. It also questions popular notions of what a rock and roll star might be like as this image suggests a rather conventional person who wears a shirt and tie, a smart corduroy jacket with trousers to match and inhabits a somewhat old-fashioned house with a wooden staircase, quite different to the characteristically brash image of a pop drummer who living a crazy sometimes drug fuelled lifestyle. The image seems to say a lot about the sitter, inviting us into his world, a world that is apparently comfortable.

The camera is placed directly in front of the viewer, there is no subtle angle and the sitter look straight at the camera although his gaze is perhaps not entirely direct. He manages a smile which is often considered inappropriate with portraiture.

The composition is clever. There are diagonal lines in the way the sitter has placed his legs (the caption tells us that this was a pose naturally adopted by the sitter that the photographer asked him to hold) while the staircase in the background reflects this with more diagonals. The placement of the feet, horizontally towards the viewer, is almost comic.

Although subdued, the location here does add atmosphere to the portrait with its subdued tones and lack of detail; the unexpected image of the sitter is being further deconstructed by an air of respectability.

AL comments that this photograph works not just because the sitter is well known but because there has been communication between the sitter and the photographer who was watching the sitter from the very beginning of the shoot.


WAFA

Although not a winning portrait, this photograph is being used to advertise the exhibition appearing not only on the front of the exhibition portfolio but also on brochures and other media. As AL points out, this decision is a marketing one and little to do with the curators and judges of the exhibition.

This photograph tends to rely on a more traditional and less challenging notion of what portrait photography might be. There is beauty here not just in the woman's face and look back also in the architectural background. Her attire suggests the Muslim religion and her appeal is bound to attract the male gaze, still a predominant force in advertising.

The camera angle is straightforward as is the case with many other images in the exhibition.

The composition contains the curvaceous lines of the subject body, face and hands, as well as clothes that contrast with the straight largely vertical lines of the architecture around her in the background. There is also some ornamentation in the detail behind her. The sitter's makeup is barely visible yet adds to the subtle tones of this image.

The caption informs us that this is a "daring" look. One wonders where this daring may lie! Is it because Muslim women are traditionally bound not to show their face in public or does the danger lie in the seductive nature of the glance?

The Spanish photographer is undertaking an art history course at a university.

AL mentions the lovely interplay of detail in the background.


UNSAFE JOURNEY

As a visitor to India, this image strikes me as a clever image but not out of the ordinary as riding on the tops of trains is quite common. On learning it was taken in Bangladesh, the reading of the image changes as Bangladesh is a predominately Muslim country in which traditionally, the place of women is subservient; here the woman is down below, in a potentially dangerous position. She looks upward not with confidence but with the air of one who is lowly.

The angle of the camera is unusual for a portrait since it is above the subject who looks upward.

The composition contains blocks of blue and green while the at the centre there are the warmer colours of the dress. Also, across the centre, is the diagonal of the woman's arm which is she is using to steady her body; it has a similar effect on the image. The rounded form of the woman sits amidst the hard lines of the sides of the gtrain that is the surrounding composition.

The Swedish photographer who made this ordinary yet striking image is a photojournalist so this was apparently never intended as a formal portrait.


After seeing the exhibition, there was not really enough time to absorb it, and making notes on a few photos, it was back to the studio to listen to AL again and enter into some discussion.

A point to note, is the way a photograph has been constructed to portray a subject. In regards to the woman on the train, the construction was largely predetermined while often in portraiture, the image can be quite carefully constructed.

There was some objection to the winning photograph which shows a young woman on a horseback on top of which is also a dead deer. The subject was considered to be too central. I felt that the subject was not just the person being portrayed but also hunting, a controversial issue; as with many of the portraits in this and previous exhibitions, there is something else going on in the picture that can compete with the sitter.


Yet the image of a huntress, a real life Diana, contains beautiful natural lighting as well as the colours of a muted palette in the woman's auburn hair, the brown of the horse and the slain animal, in the mountains of the background. Interestingly this winning image is not on the NPG website likewise another winning photo entitled My British Wife which looks up the dress of a woman to reveal her private parts. The newspapers did not print all of this photograph probably because they thought they might be prsecuted for lewdness! The photographer is Greek and as a nude, it challenges the accepted more of the Western classical art tradition since the vagina is not shown. The image is well composed with beautiful light and a beautiful model. Eyeline in the photo is slightly higher than in most of the other photographs. There is an intimacy! Shades of Gaugin and since the photographer has studied art, he was aware of the contexts and ripples of this photograph.

There are only a small number of black and white images in the exhibition about 10% of the total. Colour did not start as an acceptable medium until the mid 1980's.

The use of colour in the images is often subdued though a few contain stronger colours.

When photographing, it is good to look for interesting colours as well as tonal range, different kinds of light and con contrasts of different kinds (whether of form, colour or texture etc).

Film still used a lot by professionals; the kind of film used is important. Some are better suited to portraiture.

3 basic types of camera ... 35mm, medium format (e.g. Hassleblad) and large format (e.g. Linhof also field cameras). Still used quite a bit; gives forensic style quality. Use of both negatives and positives also prints in image processing.

What about the use of the rule of thirds, off centre placement? Better to be more aware of background elements! (maybe the rule of thirds has become a little cliched)

One photograph that people did not seem to like was that of a couple of American GIs; the female is pregnant yet one needs a caption to tell us this. There seems to be little sense of composition.

AL mentions the "freaks" of Diane Arbus.

95% IS ABOUT COMMUNICATION WITH THE SUBJECT; THE RAPPORT THE PHOTOGRAPHER OR OCCASIONALLY THE SUBJECT, ESTABLISHES!

One photo is of two scantily clad women on a doorstep. Is this how they would like to be photographed?  Ethical question!
People on the fringes of society, under-represented. Subdued colours ... not natural, awkward look.

Another photo is of an elderly lady who wears a blue jumper; the face looks away, downcast. The use of a larger format permits greater detail and feeling of texture; great detail in the hair. The caption tells us she is blind! The colours are pastel.

Another photo is of two elderly golfing ladies; they both look directly into the camera.

Captions can be enormously important and effect the gaze of the viewer; for example, my seeing the oppressed woman in the train photo as soon as I heard it was in Bangladesh. Possibly though, my view is a stereo-typed one.

CONTEXT
the way the photo is being used
the words that anchor the photo

manipulation of colour saturation
evident in some images such as that of Tony Blair
does not mean its' a bad image rather a statement
muted colours

naked male torso of person who has Parkinson's disease .. impressionistic
done by using a long open shutter with a torch being flashed a few times
mistakes OK if part of the creative act

interesting light, interesting colour
placement of subject
communicating  with subject
environment - way it relates to the subject
fill the frame - make sure all detail is relevant

Examine the whole frame; notice the edges, take more than one photograph

depth of field - amount of photograph that is in focus - usally less rather than more as it helps to concentrate the eye of the viewer rest on the subject

series of decisions made by the photographer; examining the photograph in this manner deconstructs them and is the best way to improve one's own work



photos from National Portrait Gallery workshop



PHOTOS MADE WITHOUT SUBJECT'S CONSENT



males



council sweeper who said "you are not allowed to photograph people working"



young couple



male with dreadlocks




man outside gallery listening to music



PHOTOS MADE WITH SUBJECT'S CONSENT



council officer



young male in Leicester Square



male, Leicester Square



Big Issue seller
(made with subject's consent)


Big Issue seller
(image made before previous one and without consent of subject)






Saturday, January 22, 2011

alteration : another street photograph

This is a photograph I picked out from my database, an image I took a couple of years ago, that stuck in my mind as a street photograph; it shows an alteration between two people, possibly father and son, who apparently seemed unaware of my presence ...


Alteration : Russell Square, London


I was actually photographing the surveillance camera visible in the background (upper left)!

Aimlessness - a street photograph - (and the question of aggression)

I decided to participate in a Street Photography project ...
http://streetphotographynowproject.wordpress.com/about/

The current topic was aimlessness and the photograph below was made by asking a friend to kick an empty carton from a waste bin along the edge of the pavement ...


my choice from a little over 100 photos made

While I was engaging in this simple photographic act, a security guard came out at one point and can be seen talking through a talking device of some kind. I did not notice this at the time!


A security guard checks on my activities

The photographer Andrew Glickman who studied with Joel Meyerowitz (whose instructional video on street photography is worth seeing ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Qjym5uliDw&NR=1) remarks that "Photographing people, particularly people you don't know, is an inherently aggressive act. I had to break through my comfort zone to make some of the pictures I've made. You can't worry about whether you have permission or whether you may be inside your subject's comfort zone. Believing completely in what you are doing is critical."

Does this kind of attitude explain the appearance of the security guard who thinks that I might be up to something? The extent to which photography is aggressive (a sentiment aired by Susan Sontag in her book On Photography) surely depends on the disposition of the photographer. I do not enjoy being invasive and am of course, in this instance anyway, just photographing someone I know who is happy to be photographed.

Bruce Gilden is an example of a street photographer who is up front and aggressive though one does feel he is also often being playful!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRBARi09je8&NR=1

here he talks about the "ethics" of what he is doing ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iWEzm2disjM